A new study says those calcium and vitamin D supplements may do more than just strengthen your bones - they could help you lose weight too! Here's the big skinny on getting into those skinny jeans!
By Colette Bouchez
Whether you’re struggling to lose those last 10 pounds – or facing up the task of tackling a 50 pound loss or more – take heart. Brand new study published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition says that boosting your intake of both calcium and vitamin D may be your ticket to skinny jeans!
In research conducted at Ben-Gurion University in Negrev Israel doctors discovered that dieters who had a modest calcium intake of just 580 mg daily, and maintained a blood level of vitamin D around 30 nanograms per milliliter were able to naturally and easily lose more weight over a two year period of time than those lower levels of both.
“Our study suggests that both higher dairy calcium intake and increased serum vitamin D are related to greater diet-induced weight loss,” wrote the researchers, led by Danit Shahar from Ben-Gurion University of the Negev in Israel.
This new study tosses a bit more fuel on the fire burning around the idea that calcium-rich dairy products can help you lose weight. Indeed, numerous studies have shown that increasing your intake of dairy based products while dieting could make weight loss easier.
But while many dairy products, particularly full fat milk, ice cream and cheeses do indeed offer high levels of calcium, and some, like fortified milk also offer increased vitamin D, the high fat content can have some health concerns. This includes not only an increased risk of heart disease, but possibly an increased risk of estrogen-sensitive cancers for women.
And, in fact, since hormones are stored in fat, cattle which are given hormones such as estrogen (and many are) will yield a dairy product that could, for some women, increase some health risks.
And some believe that’s too much of a trade – off for losing a few extra pounds.
And some believe that’s too much of a trade – off for losing a few extra pounds.
But if, in fact, the weight loss was tied not to the dairy products, but the calcium and vitamin D these products provide, at least theoretically, you should be able to gain the benefits without the risks by simply taking these nutrients in supplement form.
And that in fact is what one study published earlier this year has found. Reporting in the journal Nutrition and Metabolism, doctors found that patients who consumed calcium supplements containing between 1,400 and 1,500 mg daily - with or without vitamin D3 – were able to better control that dangerous “belly fat” seen in the lower trunk and develop higher muscle mass in this same area.
That said, an earlier Canadian study found that the weight-loss benefits of calcium supplements in women may be limited to those who are calcium deficient – and that no additional weight loss benefits will be derived if you’re calcium levels are already up to speed.
So, what’s a gal to do? As with all things in life, moderation could be key. If you’re not taking calcium supplements then certainly you should talk to your doctor about adding at least 1,000 mg per day in conjunction with Vitamin D.
As to adding dairy products to your weight loss diet, experts say if you stick to low-fat varieties such as low fat yogurt, milk or cheese, and limit your intake to no more than 3 to 4 servings per day, you can gain the benefits without dramatically increasing any health risks.
Also remember you can get calcium from sardines, pink salmon, soy beverages, oatmeal, kale and fortified beverages such as orange juice.
FOLLOW-UP To BONIVA'S BIG OOPS! Several weeks ago we published "Boniva's Big Oops" - wherein we pointed out that the makers of the osteoporosis drug Boniva suggest spinach as a way to increase calcium intake naturally - even though this goes against what most nutritionists recommend. Because spinach contains oxalic acid -which interferes with your body's ability to absorb calcium big time - spinach is not a good choice to increase bone health. In fact, adding it to your diet may actually reduce the amount of calcium you are able absorb from other calcium-rich foods such as milk, cheese or yogurt. Since the article appeared we heard from hundreds of you who pointed out that not only are Boniva's erroneous ads still running on TV, but that these same ads advocating spinach as a calcium-rich food have even appeared in the WebMD magazine and on their website - where we all know the docs and nutritionists on staff know better.
So...if the Boniva folks don't think enough of your health to make the change in their ads and give you the correct dietary information to stay healthy, maybe you should think twice before accepting a prescription for this drug- who knows what else they are wrong about? Either way, talk to your doctor - she'll know what's best for you. And never stop taking a prescription drug unless you check with your doctor first.
So...if the Boniva folks don't think enough of your health to make the change in their ads and give you the correct dietary information to stay healthy, maybe you should think twice before accepting a prescription for this drug- who knows what else they are wrong about? Either way, talk to your doctor - she'll know what's best for you. And never stop taking a prescription drug unless you check with your doctor first.
For the latest health, beauty and style advice for women over 40 subscribe to RedDressDiary - It's Free! And be sure to check out CheapChicDiary.com for money saving beauty and style tips!
Copyright by ElleMedia Network 2010 - All Rights Reserved. In addition to US Copyright, the text of this RedDressDiary article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License. All formatting and style elements of this page are not available under this license, and Colette Bouchez retains all rights in those elements. The creators of this blog may or may not benefit from products mentioned or featured on this web page.